Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

Skywalk Real, Amazing. Still Damn Near Impossible To See Without Going There.

So, it appears that the Grand Canyon Skywalk is real. After Peggy's investigation last year, it appears that the company making this thing, being two years late, finally managed to get a structure up.

Michael Demmons was also kind enough to email me this link about it, within minutes of Peggy sending her update to me.

Then my antannae began quivering: this was all well and good, but I examined both links carefully, and the supporting links. This thing is supposedly the 8th wonder of the World. An amazing and truly unique construction. So where the photographs?

I'm not alleging a conspiracy here. I'm certain the structure exists now, too many say they've seen it. But this has to be simply the worst, most incompetent job of marketing and press relations that I have ever seen in my life. To whit: where are the clear and impressive photos of the marvelous Skywalk?

The lack of any photo evidence--other than "artist's conceptions"--along with the apparently huge construction delays was what had me wondering what the heck was going on in the first place.

I understand that Arizona is a dark, primitive land steeped in backwardness and barbarity, and that the natives there fear the evil juju of a decent camera. Still, you'd think some Christian missionary somewhere would have managed to smuggle one past the guards in order to snap a few clear shots from a few different angles using a decent lens.

Even journalist Elizabeth Mitchell, who claims to have been there, has no photographs at this writing on her site.

This is driving me batty. How can you have story after story after story about this amazing new structure, unique in world history and a huge tourist attraction, and not have any decent goddamned photos of the thing?

Is modern-day journalism really this bad?

Finally with digging I found this pathetically bad photo, and this story with somewhat better images. Which, after much looking, turns out to be *the best* photography of this 8th wonder of the world I have yet to see in the last two years.

It's this that led me to wonder whether the whole thing was a business boondoggle/hoax in the first place--something some underfunded and/or unrealistic entrepreneur dreamed up but never actually produced, like the Moeller Sky Car.

When I first raised the question, the Grand Canyon Skywalk home page had no actual photographic evidence at all. Even now, it's mostly dominated by artist's depictions. Good lord. Who is in charge of this project? Where are the spectacular, awe-inspiring photos of this amazing and unique construction?

I repeat: I no longer doubt that it exists. But I wonder (A) who is the incompetent person on charge of press relations on this, and (B) why do Arizona reporters apparently not know how to use cameras?

I actually think this is a pretty cool construction project. I'm just dazzled at the fact that apparently no one on the entire internet--including the people who own this structure!--can supply a clear shot of this breathtaking marvel that's much better than your average smudgy picture of Bigfoot.

*Update*: Okay, here's a video. Which isn't exactly impressive, but hey, at least it's clearly Buzz Aldrin and he's walking on something. Note to Hualapai tribe: I can probably find you a cheap photographer who would give you shots that look like something more than an ex-astronaut walking around on a bridge with a microphone in his hand. Give me a call.

*Update 2*: Here is the very best photo I have managed to find so far, in all its glory and majesty:

grand canyon skywalk

Wow. Just... wow.

*Update 3*: Okay, this video is sort of cool:

Finally. That actually does look like something it would be cool to walk on. Not exactly like the artist's depictions, but nothing ever is.

(Thanks Sandi.)

Posted by Dean | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
Foobarista:
We used to call this "Stealth Marketing". It's so stealthy James Bond couldn't figure out what it is...
3.22.2007 6:28pm
Dean Esmay:
Dude, am I nuts?

Buzz Aldrin was the first to walk on it. Great. Can someone please show me a decent photo of Buzz Aldrin on it?

This isn't an "I challenge you to prove you're not lying" request. It's a "WHAT THE HECK IS WRONG WITH YOU PEOPLE?!?!?!" request.

Is it that the Hualapai are frightened of cameras? Is it that the real-life structure is far less impressive than the artist's depictions? Is there some gas in the air that kills photographers if they walk too near the area?

"Come and see the marvelous tourist attraction that we will only show you in artist's depictions and in smudgy UFO-style photos!"
3.22.2007 6:33pm
Dean Esmay:
Okay, I at least found the video. After digging.

I utterly believe that this structure exists. I'm just dumbfounded at how bad the marketing and photography are. It looks like Buzz Aldrin strolling around on a highway overpass. Whooh! Whooh! Buzz Aldrin walks around!

A junior-year j-school photographer or film school student wouldn't be this dumb. Would they?
3.22.2007 6:57pm
Jerry Kindall (www):
Well, we should see more photos next week if it opens to the public as scheduled.
3.22.2007 7:07pm
Martin L. Shoemaker (www):
My wild speculation would be that somebody's trying to put together a big smash premier event, and has issued orders to keep it low key until then. I've seen that sort of thing, where the person didn't realize that it's too late for a "surprise" style event, and you should just start getting people talking about it.
3.22.2007 7:08pm
Dean Esmay:
Because after all, when you invite all sorts of members of the press, and even invite (and almost certainly pay money for) a well-known astronaut to be there at your big press unveiling, you keep all the good photos secret.

Because that's how to really build your "Buzz." LOL.

At this point I'm going to give them "incompetent marketing." And keep wondering what's wrong with the reporters.

Maybe it's something genius and my jaw will drop next week. If so I'll admit it.
3.22.2007 7:09pm
Scott AKA TLHeart (mail):
Dean,
A video and good photo's of the skywalk were on Fox news webpage last week. The real problem right now is the fact that one can not just drive out to the skywalk and see it, it must be part of a package tour, sold by the reservation.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,259863,00.html

Now I can not find the video...

It was also on the local news here in Wyoming, Colorado.
3.22.2007 7:24pm
Martin L. Shoemaker (www):
Then there's this theory:


Damn Near Impossible To See Without Going There.


Maybe someone's trying to rake in bucks from tourists, and is afraid to let anyone see it without paying. That's not much different from a lot of museums, traveling museum shows, and even circuses that ban photography of their exhibits or acts, because they want only paying customers to see them.

The Frederick Meijer Gardens isn't so bad: they'll let you take all the pictures you want, and even blog about it. But darn it, if you want to see Da Vinci's Horse in person, you're going to pay admittance. They've sculpted a valley for it, so that you can't see it from the ground anywhere but inside the Gardens.

So maybe someone from the tribe is just overzealously trying to milk the thing for money, not understanding that tourist attractions need, ya know, tourists, and that means PR.
3.22.2007 7:25pm
Bryan Costin (mail) (www):
Don't get me started. Almost every day I run across a news story that just begs for a photo. And when there is a photo it's barely more than a thumbnail. Check on flickr in a few days and you'll probably find some nice shots from the visitors.

For a while I figured that as a photographer myself I was just spoiled or expecting too much. Now I figure they're just lazy, because I don't know what else it could be. Good cameras are cheap and easy to use, and almost anybody (even a professional journalist) can be trained to take a pretty decent photo. Maybe it's a holdover from print days, when each picture in the paper competed for valuable space with column inches and advertising.
3.22.2007 7:35pm
Dean Esmay:
Scott TLA: Dude, you're singing my song. Some story you saw on Fox News. For which video is no longer available. For which the only photograph is a chieftain standing on a rock with no evidence of the Skywalk in question.


Bryan: I'm hoping you're right. I can't believe the level of incompetence here.
3.22.2007 7:53pm
Sandi (www):
Dean, I have a 1.40 minute clip I grabbed from ABC news if you want it (I assume you have broadband). It is rather large because it is in DVD format (75MB) but I can reduce it to 320 x 240 better for blog display and probably 10-15 megs.

Or if you don't have broadband I suppose I can upload it to YouTube. There is one fair clip on YouTube, but it isn't done, although apparently near the end of construction.
3.22.2007 8:00pm
Tim_the Soldier (mail):
Awesome!!! I can't wait to visit next year...oh, FUCK RON COLEMAN!!!
3.22.2007 8:23pm
Dean Esmay:
Oh, Tim. I know you're just kidding, but you ought to consider sometimes that someone like Ron might not know you are.
3.22.2007 8:58pm
jaymaster (mail):
I saw a FOX live broadcast from bridge the other day. I’m pretty sure it was their 7:00 PM broadcast, because that’s usually when I watch them. I did a quick search but couldn’t find video.

It had some good shots. The reporter was actually jumping up and down on it at one point. Just watching it almost made my wife hurl.
3.22.2007 9:08pm
Sandi (www):
Ok, I uploaded my ABC news clip to YouTube. It isn't a whole lot better than the other clip, but it conveys some of the controversy within the Native American community.
3.22.2007 10:09pm
Dean Esmay:
Sandi: Awesome! Best footage I've seen yet!
3.22.2007 10:32pm
MDP (mail) (www):
This is driving me batty. How can you have story after story after story about this amazing new structure, unique in world history and a huge tourist attraction, and not have any decent goddamned photos of the thing? .... Finally with digging I found this pathetically bad photo, and this story with somewhat better images.
Dean, three days ago I sent you a link to this AP story and 48-pic "slideshow". No need for all the strenuous "digging" if you just read your email.
3.23.2007 3:53am
Dean Esmay:
I get more mail than I can possibly read every day, MDP. Excuse me for not seeing yours.

That is a good slide show. I wouldn't have noticed it just reading the page, but thanks for pointing it out.
3.23.2007 6:00am
Trudy W. Schuett (mail) (www):
There's also quite a bit of confusion as to whether the cost to walk on the thing is $25 or $75.

I suspect the lack of info might stem from the fact that people are going to be expecting to see THE GRAND CANYON, in other words, the well-known view from the South Rim, which is not at all what you're going to get that far west.

My son is the IT guy for Western Newspapers, which owns the Kingman Daily Miner and a bunch of other AZ and east Cal papers, so maybe I can dig around and find something out.

I doubt that I'll be able to get up there anytime soon, as I keep having to go someplace else for the job, but if/when I can, I will.
3.23.2007 7:13am
TallDave (mail) (www):
I still say it's going to fall over.
3.23.2007 11:47am
John B. Irving (mail):
For some reason Tim's comment struck me as hilarious. . . I'm just picturing him typing about how he wants to see the Grand Canyon Skywalk, and suddenly Ron Coleman appeared at his side, presumably dressed as some kind of Sith Lord.

And I might fly over the Grand Canyon someday, but I doubt I'd go out on that thing.
3.23.2007 6:39pm
Peggy (mail) (www):
Trudy,

You have to pay to take the tour which will take you back to where the walk is, and then you have to pay again - $25.00 to go on the walk. It's very very expensive.
3.24.2007 3:45pm
Account:
Password:
Remember info?
Commenting on Dean's World is a privilege, not a right. Dean is your host, you are his guest, and you should behave in that fashion. Dean is not your babysitter, nor is he your punching bag. Please remember this. In general, you are free to disagree with anyone on any subject you wish, but abusive behavior will not be tolerated.

Of course we all lose our tempers now and then. Dean freely admits to being imperfect in this regard, which is why regulars to this establishment will generally be cut more slack than people who we don't know very well.

Still: behave like an adult, or go find somewhere else to play. Thanks.