Dean's World

Defending the liberal tradition in history, science, and philosophy.

The Generosity of Comcast

After Dean's purge, something a bit lighter...

Over the past weekend I received a call from Comcast offering me a free upgrade to digital cable AND six months free of Showtime and HBO.

I paused while the CSR chattered away about all that is wonderful about Comcast. Why the heck were they offering me something for free? After all, this is the same outfit that hooked me on broadband, then jacked up my rates on cable and refused to cut me a break on their so-called "Triple Play." I've been stuck spending too much money on cable just because the Wife doesn't want a satellite dish on the house and DSL software wrecked my PC.

As she blah-blahed I caught her state that agreement meant that they were locking me into a year of service. After getting burned by bad cellphone service contracts over the years, I've gotten a bit shy about contracts that lock you into anything. But this one was weird. Other than the time period you were stuck with Comcast, they were offering me roughly $30 of services a month for free.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with Comcast, dealing with it is a lot like dealing with the Devil. You get what you asked for, but not what you want – and the price? Well, the price is always outrageous.

So why was Comcast giving me stuff for free without anything in return. Why?

Then it dawned on me: Fios - Verizon's fiberoptic network. The fiber has been sitting buried in my neighborhood, unlit for about a year. Fiber. You know they say you can never get enough fiber. How right "they" are.

Today I saw an ad for Fios in the local paper offering a $10/month discount. That fiber must be getting lit soon, and as soon as it does I am ripping the coax cable off my house for good. Freedom! Freedom!

Posted by Scott Kirwin | Permalink | Technorati Trackbacks
Dean Esmay:
Purge? Hahahaha.

"You should go somewhere else" isn't much of a purge. I'm having a hard time imagining Stalin as telling the Kulaks, "We really don't like you, you should move away or something."

Anyway:

Comcast sucks.
2.28.2007 10:52pm
Martin L. Shoemaker (www):
You've got part of it: they want to keep you off that fiber.

The other part of locking you into a contract is their valuation. I'm no stock expert, but here is how it was explained to me.

When you're on month to month with them, your payments are classified as one sort of asset, one that's risky and subject to fluctuation. But when you're on a contract, that's a guaranteed receivable for them. It counts as a different sort of asset, one which looks better on the bottom line for them.

Now it gets more important (for them) from there. Because their bottom line looks better, their stock value tends to go up. Analysts move from sell to hold or hold to buy, which bumps up the price. And today, that stock valuation matters a lot, because we keep going through periodic bursts of mergers in the communications industries. If their stock value is up, it helps them to acquire another company, because often the medium of exchange is stock, not dollars. Or if the sale is in dollars, they can sell some stock off to raise dollars, or maybe use it to collateralize loans.

Meanwhile, if they're trying to avoid being acquired, a high stock value makes them more expensive to purchase. So it's a defense. Or conversely, if they want to be acquired, then they want to get as much money for the sale as possible. So again, a high stock value is in their interest.

So the net result is that everybody in the communications business wants to lock you into a contract. And personally, I'm happy to let them lock me in, as long as there's something pretty decent in it for me. Premium packages won't cut it for me, because we don't have time to watch the channels we have now, and we own more DVDs than we could watch in a month. But if T-Mobile cuts me a deal on a good Windows Mobile phone -- say, a couple hundred off list -- I'll be happy to boost their bottom line a bit. After all, they're practically the only carrier in my neighborhood anyway, so I'm not likely to switch. I wouldn't be giving up much.
2.28.2007 10:55pm
TallDave (mail) (www):
FTTH? You're lucky, that's been a telco dream for a long time. Fiber has one billion times the capacity of cable, iirc from my telco class; that's a fat pipe.

While Comcast's customer service and employee relations suck, I've been pretty happy their service overall, esp. the on-demand stuff.

Rumor has it (via the Comcast installer guy) that we can get new DVR boxes just for asking.
2.28.2007 11:59pm
Rod Short:
I've been a Comcast Internet user for years, and I've been pretty happy with the Internet service, overall. I tend to spend a lot of time helping friends and family get on broadband and/or wireless access points setup correctly, and I've become very unhappy with the software crap Comcast and the other DSL vendors push on you. Often, your Internet connection refuses to work unless you install this crap - sometimes it's a MAC address registration issue, sometimes it's something different (like "support" software that has to call back to their server on a regular basis).

I've learned a little trick: pretend you are a Linux user. It usually goes something like this:

(Calling to Tech Support)

Me - Yeah, I'm trying to get my new Internet connection to work, but apparently nothing will happen until I install your software.

Tech - Yes, that's right! Let me help you...

Me - Wait, you don't understand. I don't use Windows or Mac. I run Linux.

Tech - Uhhmmm. You run Linux? Uh, do you have a Windows or Mac system that we can use to get the software installed?

Me - Nope. Just Linux.

Tech - *sigh* Oh, you are one of those people. Okay, let me just do [insert whatever technical explanation they use here] and it will work. Give it a try.

Me - Yep, I'm up!

Tech - Okay, thanks for calling...

I've helped 6 friends get hooked up on DSL or Comcast in the past few months and this has worked like a charm. Only once has the tech actually tried to ask me questions, like what linux distro I use, etc. Since I actually have a spare computer running linux, and I'm reasonably familiar with linux overall, it was easy to keep up with his questions until he gave up. :-)

Anyway, that's how I keep that software crap off my computers! I'm pretty envious with that fiber deal, let us know how it goes will'ya?

-Rod
3.1.2007 12:19am
Mason (mail):
As a former FIOS TV/Internet user for over a year (sadly, I recently moved out of the service area), I will wholeheartedly recommend you jump on it as fast as you can. I did not have one single problem -- the transition was smooth and the service excellent. I'm not a big fan of Verizon in general but when it comes to FIOS.. they rock.
3.1.2007 1:55am
Scott Kirwin (mail) (www):
It still amazes me how cable has pretty much gotten away with becoming a monopoly in the modern era. Living in the Northeast and having many friends who have worked at Comcast at one time or another has also shown me just how arrogant a company can be. Honestly, I would have cut over to satellite years ago if the Wife really hated the dish on the house (yet doesn't mind our collapsing gutters! WTF?)

Competition is good. We need competition in broadband and TV now more than ever.

FIOS. Yum!!!
3.1.2007 7:23am
John Eddy (mail) (www):
We were waiting breathlessly for FiOS in New Hampshire... then Verizon abandoned the entire upper North East and sold the lines to some rural carrier in South Carolina. They promise DSL...

Stuck with Comcast until my state's population grows enough to warrant real service, I guess.
3.1.2007 8:55am
TallDave (mail) (www):
It still amazes me how cable has pretty much gotten away with becoming a monopoly in the modern era.

Well, they do have satellite and DSL as competitors. Keep in mind too that they also took on MASSIVE amounts of debt building the infrastructure to turn one-way cable delivery into two-way broadband Internet.
3.1.2007 11:14am
Victor Krueger:
It must be nice to have the option of cable or dsl. Where I live your choices are dialup, satelite (which is expensive and slow) and cell phone internet (also expensive and slow). There are downsides to living in the boonies.
3.1.2007 8:25pm
Martin L. Shoemaker (www):
Victor, you must be my neighbor!

To add insult to injury, every three or four months the mice get into the nearest phone box, build a nest, and chew through the wires. I have three lines to the house, so fortunately two are still working tonight.
3.1.2007 8:48pm
JRogge:
FIOS is going to be the bane of cable. Once TV is integrated with internet capability (some cable box models do this already) and the speed and clarity are at optical speed and clarity, cable is in Big Big trouble. At the very least they will have to drop prices.
3.2.2007 11:43pm
Account:
Password:
Remember info?
Commenting on Dean's World is a privilege, not a right. Dean is your host, you are his guest, and you should behave in that fashion. Dean is not your babysitter, nor is he your punching bag. Please remember this. In general, you are free to disagree with anyone on any subject you wish, but abusive behavior will not be tolerated.

Of course we all lose our tempers now and then. Dean freely admits to being imperfect in this regard, which is why regulars to this establishment will generally be cut more slack than people who we don't know very well.

Still: behave like an adult, or go find somewhere else to play. Thanks.